An inevitability that Pope – despite being England’s established No.3 in an Ashes series – was always likely to be the first batter to fall, in what turned out to be a collapse of 5 for 38. His missed booming drive off Mitchell Starc, his loft just over cover and the edge that cleared second slip off Brendan Doggett; all were signs he should have heeded. When he bunted his drive back to Michael Neser, there was novelty to be had in Pope’s first caught-and-bowled dismissal off a seamer, but it was lost in the certainty that he was not long for this Saturday night at the Gabba. And once he was gone, he certainly wasn’t going to be alone.
Speaking on The Grade Cricketer podcast prior to the series, Mark Waugh stated Pope would not score a run. On Thursday, Waugh, while commentating on Triple M, dismissed Pope as “just a player” moments before the right-hander danced across to the off-side and chopped Mitchell Starc onto his own stumps for a duck.
In the build-up to this series, Ben Stokes and Brendon McCullum reiterated to the team that the coming weeks were an opportunity to define their legacy. The fact that they (understandably) hid from their players was that Ashes tours can rob you of your dignity and self-worth. Worst still, they can undo whatever goodwill you have with your own fans.
That in itself makes Pope an interesting case study of where we are all are, after just five days of actual cricket. From the moment he called a newly appointed Stokes at the start of the 2022 summer to pitch for the No.3 position, Pope became emblematic of the initial merits of the project and, now, of the flaws that are threatening to bubble over and scald English cricket.
Now, that debate may be back on the agenda, and not unreasonably. But perhaps it is important to step back and see the bigger picture. England’s dream-weaving over the last three years, while not without merit, has somehow trapped Pope – one of the most popular players in a closed-off dressing room, and the ultimate team man – in a nightmarish web of doubt and technical uncertainty, even while it continues to masquerade as a never-ending pursuit of clarity and a unwavering desire to be assertive.
It is important to state that Pope has spent the last couple of months working hard to correct the flaws that he would never publicly admit. In the first innings at Perth, he was crisp with his straight driving, having overcome a tendency to fall away to the off side, while seemingly ridding himself of his tick outside off stump. Both traits seem to have returned, which does not suggest Pope has been slacking behind the scenes since arriving in Australia, but that the work he’s done is not quite ingrained. By the time he’s comfortable with his tweaks, he may well be out of the team.
It may be too late for all this to correct itself: the match situation in this second Test and thus the Ashes itself. There will be deep introspection and, when the worst is confirmed, casualties.
Pope is likely to be one of them, but he should also be seen as a lesson to heed. The biggest advocate for what Stokes and McCullum have created is now one of its more serious problems. The sparkle he once had has been lost. The joy with which he played the game is a distant memory.
Pope arrived on this tour looking to make up for his own torrid time in 2021-22 when – as a bit-part player – he averaged 11.17 and ended up out of the team. Little did he know that, four years later, he’d return as the centre-piece of the top five, as an ambassador of the good work done over the last three years, only for his ordeal to be so much worse.
Vithushan Ehantharajah is an associate editor at ESPNcricinfo
