Tata Technologies was widely seen as a landmark listing for the Tata Group. When the stock debuted in November 2023, it surged to around Rs 1,200, fuelled by strong subscription demand and expectations of sustained growth in engineering and research services. The initial rally reflected a broader belief that India’s ER&D space would benefit from global outsourcing trends and increasing demand for digital engineering.
That optimism proved short-lived. The stock has since slipped to around Rs 562, marking a sharp erosion in value. The decline has been gradual but persistent, with little sustained recovery despite intermittent rebounds.
The core issue, according to analysts, is structural rather than cyclical. Tata Technologies derives a significant portion of its revenue from Tata Motors and Jaguar Land Rover. Both these clients have faced demand and profitability pressures, which have in turn affected the company’s growth trajectory. This dependence has created a concentration risk that the market has increasingly begun to price in.
Brokerage Elara Capital, which maintains a cautious stance, noted that even after efforts to diversify, “the contribution of anchor clients is still 50% and this segment may continue to be weak.” It retained a sell rating, arguing that meaningful re-rating would require either a revival in spending by these clients or faster growth in non-automotive segments.
To its credit, Tata Technologies has been expanding its presence in aerospace and industrial engineering services, where growth has been more stable. However, these segments still form a smaller share of overall revenue. Analysts say the transition is happening, but not at a pace fast enough to offset weakness in core automotive-linked business.
In contrast, Bajaj Housing Finance’s decline is less about operational weakness and more about valuation correction. The company, part of the Bajaj Group, entered the market with a strong franchise in housing finance, focusing on relatively low-risk segments such as prime home loans and lease rental discounting.The stock listed at around Rs 163 and initially held investor interest, but has since corrected to about Rs 90. While the fall is comparable in magnitude to Tata Technologies, the underlying drivers are different.
Bajaj Housing Finance continues to report steady business growth, supported by demand in the premium housing segment and a disciplined lending approach. However, the broader environment for housing finance companies has turned challenging. Elevated interest rates have increased the cost of funds, while competition among lenders has intensified, putting pressure on margins.
Brokerages say the stock had priced in strong growth expectations at the time of listing, leaving little room for disappointment. As macro conditions tightened, valuations began to compress.
HDFC Securities said that despite “best-in-class fundamentals,” the stock faced valuation headwinds following a steep correction. It added that the company’s ability to sustain return on equity while moderating growth will be a key factor for future re-rating.
Strong listing gains often reflect liquidity, brand perception and scarcity premium rather than underlying earnings visibility. Once the stock begins trading in the secondary market, these factors tend to fade, and valuation becomes more closely tied to performance.
In both cases, the initial narrative was compelling. Tata Technologies was positioned as a play on global engineering outsourcing, while Bajaj Housing Finance was seen as a stable compounder in a structurally growing segment. However, the market has since recalibrated expectations based on actual growth delivery and macro conditions.
(Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of Economic Times)